New Delhi (Gurpreet Singh): The Supreme Court has issued notice on a review petition seeking to reopen a war injury pension case after the Centre informed it that the World War II veteran who was awarded the benefit had died nearly two years before the Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT) passed its order.
A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justice SVN Bhatti said it would examine whether the court had been misled during the proceedings. The bench also directed the Army to trace the legal heirs of former Rifleman Govind Singh Rawat and submit a report at the next hearing.
The court asked the concerned Senior Superintendent of Police and Station House Officer to assist the Army in identifying Rawat’s family.
“If fraud has been played on court, we have to detect it,” the bench observed while hearing the review petition filed by the Centre, the Chief of Army Staff and others.
Centre Alleges Possible Fraud In Pension Claim
The Centre is seeking a review of the Supreme Court’s October 17, 2023, judgment, which had dismissed its appeal against the AFT’s decision to grant Rawat a war injury pension.
The AFT’s Lucknow bench had ordered the pension on June 4, 2021, after Rawat approached the tribunal on September 9, 2020. The tribunal had also limited the arrears to three years preceding the filing of the petition.
However, the Army reportedly discovered that Rawat had died on January 17, 2019, only when it began processing the pension payment. It also found that the person who had pursued the case before the tribunal was Subedar Major and Honorary Captain Gamal Singh Rawat.
Additional Solicitor General Archana Pathak Dave, appearing for the Centre, told the Supreme Court that the government had obtained the death certificate but was yet to identify the veteran’s legal heirs.
She said the person who had pursued the case was represented by a lawyer throughout the tribunal proceedings. His death came to light when the Army sought bank details and cancelled cheques to process the payment.
The Centre’s review petition has described the discovery as a new and vital fact and alleged that Gamal Singh Rawat may have obtained a judicial order by pursuing the case in the name of the deceased veteran.
The Army also informed the court that its records showed no relationship between Gamal Singh Rawat and Govind Singh Rawat. It further stated that Gamal had provided his own bank details to receive the pension benefits.
Supreme Court Questions Army’s Failure To Verify Veteran’s Death
The bench questioned why the Army had not established whether Rawat was alive when the pension case was being contested before the tribunal.
When the Centre’s counsel said the veteran had been represented by an advocate, the bench remarked, “His advocate was present, not he.”
The court also pointed out that the Army had military intelligence resources that could have helped verify the relevant details.
The Army, meanwhile, submitted that it had received no information about Rawat’s death before his service records were destroyed in 2000.
World War II Veteran Was Injured In Italy
According to his service records, Govind Singh Rawat joined the Royal Garhwal Rifles in September 1941, during the Second World War. He was reportedly injured while serving in a battle in Italy and was invalidated out of service on April 6, 1947.
More than six decades later, in 2011, he approached the Garhwal Rifles regiment seeking the war injury element of his pension.
The Principal Controller of Defence Accounts (Pension), Allahabad, returned his claim as “unactioned”, stating that war injury pension was applicable to soldiers killed or disabled during the 1971, 1965 and 1962 wars, or the 1947-48 operations.
The rejection order was issued on June 26, 2020, and communicated to Rawat the following month. The case subsequently reached the Armed Forces Tribunal, which ruled in his favour in June 2021.
The Supreme Court has now sought details of Rawat’s legal heirs as it examines the Centre’s review plea. No finding of fraud has been made by the court at this stage.
