Delhi (Rajeev Sharma): The Delhi Police have told the Supreme Court that social media content creators who make and commercially publish reels cannot automatically claim the legal protections available to professional journalists while cReel-Makers Cannot Claim Journalistic Protection Automatically, Delhi Police Tell Supreme Court
The Delhi Police have told the Supreme Court that social media content creators who make and commercially publish reels cannot automatically claim the legal protections available to professional journalists while covering protests. The police have argued that journalists and reel-makers belong to different categories, and their roles must be assessed accordingly.
The submission was made through affidavits filed by Delhi Police Commissioner Anurag Kumar and Joint Commissioner of Police Surender Kumar in response to petitions alleging police misconduct against media personnel during protests at Jantar Mantar last month. The demonstrations were held against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar.
The petitions were filed by the Network of Women in Media, Free Speech Collective, Delhi Union of Journalists and other media organisations, which raised concerns over alleged police excesses against journalists covering the demonstrations.
In its response, the Delhi Police stated that some participants at what it described as unauthorised protests were social media content creators carrying cameras and microphones while recording videos for YouTube and other platforms. According to the police, this created practical difficulties for personnel in distinguishing professional reporters from individuals producing digital content for other purposes.
The affidavits clarified that the police had no intention of preventing content creators from pursuing their activities. However, they maintained that carrying recording equipment alone does not establish someone as a journalist. The predominant purpose behind an individual’s activity could be an important factor in determining whether they are performing journalistic duties or creating content for commercial use.
The police also emphasised that they respect the role of the press and have never intended to obstruct legitimate journalistic work, either during the Jantar Mantar protests or on other occasions.
Referring to an earlier Supreme Court direction concerning the protection of journalists, the Delhi Police argued that such safeguards are intended to facilitate professional reporting and do not provide blanket exemption from general laws or lawful police instructions to social media influencers, reel-makers or individuals involved in disorderly conduct at prohibited assemblies.
The police further stated that the question of whether social media reel-makers should be accorded the same status as journalists or reporters remains open for consideration. The distinction, they said, was highlighted to explain the operational challenges faced by law enforcement personnel while managing demonstrations.overing protests. The police have argued that journalists and reel-makers belong to different categories, and their roles must be assessed accordingly.
The submission was made through affidavits filed by Delhi Police Commissioner Anurag Kumar and Joint Commissioner of Police Surender Kumar in response to petitions alleging police misconduct against media personnel during protests at Jantar Mantar last month. The demonstrations were held against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar.
The petitions were filed by the Network of Women in Media, Free Speech Collective, Delhi Union of Journalists and other media organisations, which raised concerns over alleged police excesses against journalists covering the demonstrations.
In its response, the Delhi Police stated that some participants at what it described as unauthorised protests were social media content creators carrying cameras and microphones while recording videos for YouTube and other platforms. According to the police, this created practical difficulties for personnel in distinguishing professional reporters from individuals producing digital content for other purposes.
The affidavits clarified that the police had no intention of preventing content creators from pursuing their activities. However, they maintained that carrying recording equipment alone does not establish someone as a journalist. The predominant purpose behind an individual’s activity could be an important factor in determining whether they are performing journalistic duties or creating content for commercial use.
The police also emphasised that they respect the role of the press and have never intended to obstruct legitimate journalistic work, either during the Jantar Mantar protests or on other occasions.
Referring to an earlier Supreme Court direction concerning the protection of journalists, the Delhi Police argued that such safeguards are intended to facilitate professional reporting and do not provide blanket exemption from general laws or lawful police instructions to social media influencers, reel-makers or individuals involved in disorderly conduct at prohibited assemblies.
The police further stated that the question of whether social media reel-makers should be accorded the same status as journalists or reporters remains open for consideration. The distinction, they said, was highlighted to explain the operational challenges faced by law enforcement personnel while managing demonstrations.
