New Delhi (Rajeev Sharma): The Supreme Court on Tuesday sought the Election Commission’s response to an application filed by Congress leader Rahul Gandhi and other INDIA bloc leaders seeking permission to put 48 specific questions to the poll panel over alleged irregularities in the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. The Opposition leaders have claimed that flaws in the exercise resulted in large-scale voter deletions and raised concerns over what they describe as “vote theft”.
A three-judge Bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana deferred the matter to December 9. The court said it would consider the request to serve interrogatories on the Election Commission after receiving the poll panel’s objections.
Appearing for Gandhi, senior advocate Kapil Sibal informed the Bench that an application had been filed on Monday challenging the Election Commission’s counter-affidavit dated October 26. He requested the court to issue notice to the Commission and allow the petitioners to submit 48 questions concerning the conduct and authorisation of the SIR exercise.
Senior advocate Harish Salve, representing the Election Commission, told the court that the poll panel had serious reservations about the application. Responding to his submission, the Chief Justice said the Commission could file its reply and raise objections, adding that the Bench would examine the request before taking a decision.
Opposition Seeks Answers on SIR Approval and Voter Deletions
The 48 proposed questions reportedly cover the authorisation of the SIR, approvals and objections, access to databases, alleged voter exclusions and changes to online electoral registration systems. The INDIA bloc leaders have sought responses through affidavits from Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, and Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu.
The application questions whether the nationwide revision was approved collectively by the three-member Election Commission or whether the Chief Election Commissioner exercised the panel’s powers without the knowledge or concurrence of the other commissioners.
The petitioners have also pointed out that the Commission has not disclosed relevant file numbers, dates or meeting minutes to support its claim that the decision to conduct the SIR was taken unanimously.
They have referred to an August 2025 Right to Information response, which reportedly stated that no decision had been taken to initiate a nationwide SIR at that time. According to the application, the Election Commission’s affidavits make assertions but do not provide crucial official records relating to the exercise.
The Opposition leaders have further argued that courts can direct public officials to answer specific questions when information central to a constitutional challenge remains within the exclusive knowledge of the authority concerned. They have sought permission to question the Chief Election Commissioner, the two other Election Commissioners and the Director General of IT.
Election Commission Denies Allegations
The Election Commission has maintained that the decision to conduct the SIR was taken unanimously by its three members and has denied allegations of wrongdoing.
The latest application follows the Supreme Court’s October 15 order issuing notices to the poll panel and other respondents on a petition filed by Rahul Gandhi, Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge and nine other Opposition leaders. The petition alleged widespread irregularities and claimed that around 13 crore voters were deleted during the electoral roll revision. It also sought suspension of the ongoing SIR exercise.
The Election Commission subsequently filed its response rejecting the allegations. However, the petitioners have now questioned the details provided in that affidavit and are seeking further disclosures from the officials responsible for the exercise.
The Supreme Court will take up the matter again on December 9, after the Election Commission submits its objections to the proposed 48 interrogatories.
